Back to Water glossary

Water glossary

Disinfection Byproducts (DBPs): Formation, Influencing Factors, and Types

Understand how Disinfection Byproducts (DBPs) form in water treatment, the factors influencing their creation, and various types, including halogenic and non-halogenic compounds.

Water disinfection is a critical process for safeguarding public health by eliminating pathogenic microorganisms. For over a century, chemical disinfectants like chlorine have been indispensable in drinking water treatment. However, research in the 1970s, notably through gas chromatography testing, revealed the formation of Disinfection Byproducts (DBPs) during this process. These chemical compounds, formed from the reaction of disinfectants with naturally occurring organic matter in water, can pose health concerns, necessitating careful management and mitigation strategies.

What Are Disinfection Byproducts (DBPs)?

Disinfection Byproducts (DBPs) are chemical substances—organic and inorganic—that originate when disinfectants react with natural organic matter (NOM) or other compounds present in the water being treated.

How Are DBPs Formed?

The primary mechanism for DBP formation involves the reaction of disinfectants, such as chlorine, with naturally occurring compounds in the water matrix. This process predominantly occurs through interactions with organic substances like humic acids and fulvic acids, which are derived from the decomposition of plant matter and commonly found in natural water sources.

Early work in the 1970s by Bellar and colleagues showed that chlorination could form chloroform and other haloforms from water constituents. It helped establish that compounds detected in finished water could originate during treatment, rather than only entering with the raw water.

The exact chemical structures of humic and fulvic acids are complex and variable, making a precise understanding of DBP formation mechanisms challenging. The diverse composition of natural organic matter further complicates research into these reactions.

Factors Influencing DBP Formation

The characteristics and concentrations of DBPs are influenced by a combination of factors:

1. Disinfectant Type, Dose, and Residual

The choice of disinfectant (e.g., chlorine, chloramines, ozone, chlorine dioxide) directly impacts the types of DBPs formed. Generally, higher disinfectant doses and residual concentrations lead to increased DBP formation. To mitigate the formation of halogenic DBPs, alternative disinfectants are sometimes employed, though they may still produce other types of DBPs.

2. Disinfection Conditions

The operational parameters during disinfection significantly affect DBP generation:

  • Reaction Time: THMs often continue to accumulate with contact time while reactive precursors and disinfectant remain. HAAs and unstable compounds such as Haloacetonitriles (HANs) and Haloketones (HKs) may form and then degrade, depending on the conditions. A longer time does not increase every DBP, and a shorter time does not universally produce more THMs or HAAs.
  • Temperature: Higher temperatures can accelerate DBP formation and the decomposition of some unstable DBPs. They also affect disinfectant decay and microbial inactivation. Required dose must be established for the actual demand and treatment target; warmer water does not automatically require a higher chlorine concentration.
  • pH: pH levels play a crucial role. At higher pH values, hypochlorite ions (OCl⁻) become more prevalent, reducing the efficacy of chlorine disinfection. Higher pH typically favors THM formation, while lower pH promotes HAA formation. High pH also increases hydrolysis reactions, leading to the decomposition of HANs and HKs. It is noteworthy that THM levels in distribution networks are often higher than at treatment plants, partly due to ongoing DBP formation and hydrolysis reactions converting other DBPs into THMs.

3. Water Constituents

The inherent composition of the raw water is a primary determinant of DBP formation:

  • Concentrations and Properties of Natural Organic Matter (NOM): NOM is the precursor to DBPs. Its concentration is typically measured as Total Organic Carbon (TOC) or Dissolved Organic Carbon (DOC). The specific composition of NOM—including humic acids, fulvic acids, hydrophobic acids, hydrophilic acids, and various neutral substances—dictates the types and concentrations of DBPs generated.
    • Research indicates a correlation between organic carbon concentration and the formation of various THM types, especially at different bromine concentrations.
  • Seasonal Variations: Seasonal changes affect NOM concentrations in source waters, leading to fluctuations in DBP levels throughout the year.
  • Source Water Type: DBP concentrations can vary significantly between surface water and groundwater sources due to differences in their NOM content and other water quality parameters.

Types of Disinfection Byproducts

DBPs can be broadly categorized into organohalogenic, inorganic, and non-halogenic compounds, depending on the disinfectant used and the precursor compounds present. The table below outlines common DBPs associated with various disinfectants:

DisinfectantOrganohalogenic DBPsInorganic DBPsNon-Halogenic DBPs
Chlorine (Cl₂)/Hypochlorous Acid (HOCl)Trihalomethanes (THMs), Haloacetic Acids (HAAs), Haloacetonitriles, Chloral Hydrate, Chlorophenols, Organic ChloraminesChlorate, particularly from hypochlorite production or storageAldehydes and carboxylic acids under some conditions
Chlorine Dioxide (ClO₂)Not the principal products of chlorine dioxide alone; combinations with other disinfectants can change the profileChlorite, ChlorateOxidized organic compounds, depending on the water matrix
Chloramines (NH₂Cl, etc.)Organic chloramines, Haloacetonitriles and other nitrogen-containing DBPs; some THMs and HAAs may also occurNitrite and nitrate can be associated with nitrification, rather than direct chloramination aloneNitrosamines and other organic products under relevant precursor conditions
Ozone (O₃)Brominated organic products can occur when bromide and suitable organic precursors are presentBromate when bromide is present; iodate and hydrogen peroxide may also occurAldehydes, ketones, ketoacids and carboxylic acids

AquaChain Engineering Tip

When managing DBPs, reduce relevant precursors before primary disinfection where feasible. Enhanced coagulation, adsorption, NF or RO can remove portions of dissolved NOM; UF mainly removes particles and colloids and does not necessarily remove low-molecular-weight dissolved precursors. Confirm TOC/DOC removal and DBP formation potential for the actual water while preserving the required microbial barriers.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: What are the primary health concerns associated with DBPs?

A1: Toxicological studies and epidemiological associations have raised concerns about cancer and reproductive or developmental outcomes for some DBPs. Risks differ between compounds and exposure levels; associations do not prove that each regulated DBP causes these outcomes at every drinking-water concentration.

Q2: Can DBPs be completely eliminated from drinking water?

A2: Complete elimination of DBPs is challenging due to the inherent presence of natural organic matter and the necessity of disinfection. The goal of water treatment is to minimize their formation to acceptable regulatory levels while maintaining effective pathogen control.

Q3: What advanced treatment methods can help reduce DBP formation?

A3: Options include enhanced coagulation, granular activated carbon (GAC), nanofiltration and reverse osmosis, matched to the precursors. UV and chlorine dioxide produce different treatment and DBP profiles; verify microbial inactivation, residual requirements and byproducts rather than assuming an alternative is free of DBPs.

For the wider treatment process, see drinking water.